And there ends the ethical side of this piece, so for the squeamish among you, a click of the back button or a swift scroll down or up, is recommended. For the rest, here comes the disclaimer.
I am not raising myself on a pedestal and looking down contemptuously on those less fortunate than me.
I am not poking fun at people to whom life has dealt a difficult hand.
I am not turning preachy and saying "get a job and stop begging!!" either.
What I am however, endeavouring to do is to compile and hammer out a set of observations and things I've picked up and seen over time to create a little list (by no means complete nor definitive) of "begging techniques" I have witnessed. As a wannabe journalist, it would actually be wrong of me not to document all this, so again, easy with the brickbats.
Before "techniques" came about, there was the very simple and basic statement of need, accompanied by an outstretched palm facing the sky. No pretense here, no emotional blackmail, merely, expressing the fact that one was in need and required a bit of a monetary push. Polio is one of those conditions that is rampant in this country of ours and consequently, a number of streetdwellers are affected by it. Similar to the basic statement of need is the demonstration of need. Through this, one would walk up and show one's affected limb and ask for the aforementioned monetary push.
Soon after, came the facilitated tears method, whereby a mother would pinch her infant, causing the little one to explode into tears and the sight of a weeping infant would induce the extraction of a bit of pocket change from the wallets of the alms-giver and into the mother's hand. Bada bing bada boom!
Coercion through spiritual sentiment is next on this list, with "Allah ke naam pe de-de" or "Bhagvaan tumhara bhala karega" topping the list of most-heard phrases. This method seems to try and create within the potential giver, a feeling that blessed will they be, should they cough up some dough. In my humble opinion, this is where emotional blackmail began kicking in into the "techniques".
Moving into the present and looking at some slightly more "contemporary techniques", there's the insistence of nourishment method, which involves children insisting that they will buy food and often, specifying just what they'll buy. This probably stems from the widespread notion (misguided or not, it's not my place to comment) that alms are swiftly spent on alcohol or a quick fix of crack. Furthering this "technique", is the medicine packaging method, which usually involves an empty aluminium and plastic wrapper, used usually to package tablets and capsules. Said wrapper is shown by the potential alms acceptor to the potential giver as a way of establishing that one requires the money for medicines. Again, it is not the purpose of this piece to judge, but there is no way of telling where the wrapper emerged from and whether the person actually needs the medication.
Next up, are some of the stranger methods I have observed. The first of these is the scare shitless through abuse method, which involves loud and raucous abusive screams aimed at the potential giver as a way to guilt/scare them into making with the moolah. An example of this is screams of " <Expletive> Bhooke ke pet par laath maarta hai,
Finally, and possibly the most bizarre "technique" of all is the earthquake method. This is usually executed while the potential giver is in some sort of vehicle, generally a taxi. Potential acceptor will position oneself next to the door and attempt to use the statement of need method. If that fails, one will grab the car door in tandem with an accomplice grabbing the boot of the car. They will both proceed to rock the car from side to side until it irritates the driver of the car and he/she is forced to get out of the car and make them disperse. It is unclear as to what exactly this particular method achieves, but suffice it to say that experiencing this method once, is enough.
And that brings this little list to an end. Additions, comments and criticism will be most appreciated.
3 comments:
'The earthquake method'... quite interesting.. never come across it.
for a long time i used to think that the bhajan gangs in local trains sang to collect money... and well.. i jus got to knwo that they sang cus they felt like.. it awas more of a 'time pass' for them... weird... at times 'god' is more of a punching bag- or rather an endless pit - where all the blames in the world can be dumped... at the same time taking endless liberties on the same!
And well heres something interesting to think about... 'Have you ever seen a sardar beg?' ... very very very rare... or even nt possible i must say...! Its something the surds imbibe into their attitude from their culture... they will toil and rough it out.. rather than beg,... its interesting hw they would help uplift their community and also the others via gurudwaras... they would provide one with the basic necessities to survive and progress... food and shelter being the most imp ones...
Also, often you must have been encountered by these lost/confused/deranged/helpless couples with a kid on the streets... who ask you for help - for food - and shelter... at times its freaky man... what would a small family be doing in this strange city in such circumstances... are they cons or are do they genuinely need some help? But if that was the case.. then why is it such a common thing to find such nomadic failures?????
This reminds me of something I saw a couple of months ago. I was in the bus at a traffic signal at Worli Naka, waiting for the light to change. There was a young beggar girl...probably around 8 or 9. She had a baby in her arms who might have been around 6 months old. The baby caught my attention because it was the fairest baby I had ever seen being used to beg for alms at a traffic signal. He (I think it was a 'he') had light brown curly hair, and was really very cute. It was just so shocking, and in the 1 minute and 20 seconds that the signal took to change to green, I was staring, fixated. We've all heard about babies from affluent families being stolen and other families-in-need selling their kids in this "begging business" but seeing something like this first hand was awful.
Interesting way of putting across daily observations.
I never would have thought that it was possible to classify begging techniques, and you've done it excellently.
The only minor problem is that the post is a bit long. If you could maybe compress it a little bit, it'd be easier to go through.
As always, the writing style is excellent and incisive.
Post a Comment